I am sitting at my laptop having spent the last few minutes
wondering whether using the words “hefty” and “substantial” would be too much
in a single sentence. Both words carry quite a bit of weight, in the
metaphorical sense, and as I stared at the phrase I had the vivid sensation
that I was balancing a chemical equation. As I continue to edit with more and
more detail, this problem of weight occurs more frequently.
The specific sentence I was working with started out simply
enough. I have a habit of using filler sentences when writing in order to get
an idea out quickly so that I can move on before the rest of the information I
have shoved between my ears vanishes like a northern summer. It read as so:
“He
finished giving Erin a quick, but kind handshake and went on his way.”
Sometimes I don’t notice these
filler phrases as I write them and only notice them (or someone else does…)
when it comes time to edit. I have decided not to see them as sloppy work or a
bad habit as they allow me to finish writing without getting stuck contemplating
one sentence for hours. Of course, these simple sentences aren’t always boring;
often they are necessary. However, the “he” in this sentence is an important
character and this is his first appearance. He deserves more than to have his
actions told; he deserves to have them shown.
In trying to breathe some life
into this sentence I originally changed it to:
“He finished giving
Erin a quick but kind handshake and exited through a hefty door that shut with
a substantial hiss.”
This was better, but not right. It was a matter of weight
that made me pause and feel like this phrase was unfinished. Here, I use both
the words “hefty” and “substantial,” and the overall feeling of this sentence
has become ultimately too heavy. Much
like balancing a chemical equation, breaking up this sentence would yield an
uneven and overall erroneous result.
The word “hefty” felt right. The imagined doors were thick
metal, held shut with locks and akin to something you’d see in a hospital
setting. That left me contemplating the use of the word “substantial.” Would a
door be described as shut with a “substantial hiss?” This thought lead me to
ponder what other sorts of objects made hissing sounds when active. I
immediately thought of a steam pipe. As vapor exits venting along a series of
pipes, wouldn’t that make a strong hissing sound? Yes, and it’d be substantial.
Much more substantial than the shutting of a door.
Eureka!
I was able to fix the sentence quickly after this
realization and felt greatly empowered as I did so.
Logic works with writing as well as chemistry; what a wonderful feeling! And so, after the addition of a few more words to balance the sentence, a weak filler phrase eventually became:
Logic works with writing as well as chemistry; what a wonderful feeling! And so, after the addition of a few more words to balance the sentence, a weak filler phrase eventually became:
“Dr. Wallace gave Erin a quick, but kind handshake and pressed
forward, exiting expeditiously through a hefty door that shut with a soft
hiss.”
As a recent grad from university, I am always stuck with using adverbs. This is because with academic papers, I am always told not to use descriptions that aren't quantifiable.
ReplyDeleteThat said, it's nice to see someone else's thought process in choosing words! I especially enjoy your writing in this blog! It's certainly different from my style; that helps improve my perspectives, for sure.
What I would've done different in the sentence is to use Dr. Wallace's action to reinforce what the door feels like. Did he force his way through it? Did he has to apply extra strength, without seeming strained?
Thank you for your comments! What a great perspective! I wouldn't have thought use Dr. Wallace's action in that way here. I like that idea!
DeleteI have the same issue with adverb usage. I write up a lot of health histories for nursing school and we are taught to cut out must extraneous words and adverbs are used sparingly and carefully. Same with adjectives. Most adjectives have already been chosen for us. If the patient has a yellowing look to her, she is of a sallow complexion, for example.
It can be tough switching modes!
Ha, I'm giggling at my first three sentences in that last comment; three exclamation marks! Lots of excitement!
DeleteHahaha excitement is good for writing, yeah?
DeleteAh, switching between health histories and writing for fun sounds like trying to overcome jet-lag. But I bet you could write some really good novels on doctors and hospitals!
It is certainly appropriate to compare the medical to literary switch to jet lag. I have to push through the crappy writing I get for the first few minutes before anything decent comes out.
DeleteThe medical world has inspired a lot in me so far, it will be interesting to see where else it takes me.